Which prepaid US carrier for unlocked iPhone?

[acunningham]

I have an iPhone 3GS. It's unlocked, so not tied to any carrier. I'll be visiting the US (San Francisco) for around two months. I'm looking for a carrier offering a prepaid voice (around 3 hours per month, mostly international) and data (around 100MB per month) package. Which carrier would you recommend?

[whmurray]

Only two choices are AT&T and T-Mobile. AT&T is acknowledged to have better 3G data coverage. I had a prepaid account with them for about a year. Was generally pleased. Just went into an AT&T store to set it up. Gave them a credit card number. They automatically charged it each month. However, one does not need to set up the automatic charge; can do it manually. If I went over the max, could authorize extra charge over the phone. When I put the phone on a family plan, I just called them and they closed out the automatic debit. About as painless as it could be.

[flyingember]

before you pick read all of this article

AT&T signals an abrupt end for some prepaid iPhone plans (updated)

[acunningham]

Thank you, I'll visit the AT&T store when I arrive and see if they're still offering prepaid data plans.

[whmurray]

Originally Posted by flyingember

before you pick read all of this article

AT&T signals an abrupt end for some prepaid iPhone plans (updated)

Not to worry. The issue here were people who were on a pre-pay plan that was not intended for iPhone data. Those who were on such a plan AND who updated to new software might have to change plans. It does not apply to any new contracts or subscriptions.

There is a plan intended for iPhone which will work fine. It is intended for people who did not get their phone from AT&T, did not get a discount from AT&T, and who do not require or want a long-term contract. This is the one that I was on until two weeks ago and which worked fine. Not to worry.

[Regular readers of this forum will recognize that I am not exactly an AT&T fan-boy. However, let's not make problems where there aren't any.]

[JFSikora]

Originally Posted by whmurray

Not to worry. The issue here were people who were on a pre-pay plan that was not intended for iPhone data. Those who were on such a plan AND who updated to new software might have to change plans. It does not apply to any new contracts or subscriptions.

There is a plan intended for iPhone which will work fine. It is intended for people who did not get their phone from AT&T, did not get a discount from AT&T, and who do not require or want a long-term contract. This is the one that I was on until two weeks ago and which worked fine. Not to worry.

[Regular readers of this forum will recognize that I am not exactly an AT&T fan-boy. However, let's not make problems where there aren't any.]

You're not a fan-boy?! Get outta here... What happened to heading off to Verizon???

[whmurray]

Originally Posted by JFSikora

You're not a fan-boy?! Get outta here... What happened to heading off to Verizon???

I have my Verizon MiFi and my Verizon account. Routinely use them to "tether" my PCs and my iPhone to one another (e.g., Air Share, Air Mouse, iClicker) and to the Internet over Verizon/CDMA/3G. Have used them to do VoIP (Skype and TruPhone) over 3G cellular; looks to the iPhone as though the traffic is going via WiFi.

I am hoping for BT headset support from Skype or TruPhone (perhaps after 3.1 firmware); do not like having to hold the phone. Skype does support speakerphone but one would not want to use it in a public place.

Could give up AT&T altogether if Skype was a little better at handling incoming calls and voice mail. Perhaps soon.

Of course, even this expensive alternative to "the steaming pile of failure" does not permit MMS because the messaging functionality depends on cellular, never works over IP.

I am responding to you here because you raise the issue here. Perhaps you will wish to copy it to a more appropriate thread.